This paper investigates the impact of World War II on the relative productivity performance of the three major western belligerents, Germany, Britain and the United States in manufacturing. Partially drawing on previous work, we present two consistent labour-productivity benchmarks for 20 industry groups: comparing the USA with the UK in ...
(Show more)This paper investigates the impact of World War II on the relative productivity performance of the three major western belligerents, Germany, Britain and the United States in manufacturing. Partially drawing on previous work, we present two consistent labour-productivity benchmarks for 20 industry groups: comparing the USA with the UK in 1935 and 1950, and West Germany with the UK in 1935/6 and 1951. We follow the industry-of-origin approach using industry PPPs as currency conversion factor. Overall, we find that the US productivity lead over Europe was extended across the 1940s. By contrast, Germany fell behind substantially even compared to Britain. West Germany commanded an 8% lead in manufacturing value-added per working hour in 1936, but was lagging behind its major European rival by about 13% in 1951.
Second, we use decomposition analysis to determine the industry origins of relative labour-productivity growth across the war. We isolate the impact of structural change from intra-sector effects, and estimate the relative contribution of each industry group to shifts in the relative productivity position of the three economies. We find that America’s pulling ahead and Germany’s falling behind was driven by industries critical for the war effort, such as iron and steel, chemicals, machinery and vehicles.
Third, we provide industry-level growth accounts for West Germany and the US between 1939 and 1944, in order to show whether productivity in the war industries had already begun to diverge during the war, or whether this divergence resulted entirely from differences in the scale of war-induced dislocation after 1945. While US manufacturing achieved enormous efficiency gains the falling behind of Germany in the productivity race began before the collapse of the Nazi war economy. Between 1939 and 1944, West German industrial TFP declined by three per cent. Overinvestment in heavy industry and the increasingly acute shortage of skilled labour depressed capital productivity. By contrast, the production miracle in American industry was driven by labour expansion and improved capacity utilisation, which was made possible by the fact that US output had been substantially below its full employment level before 1941.
(Show less)